Menu of TONY'S - Downtown Sandusky in Sandusky, Ohio, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 115 W Water St in Sandusky, OH, TONY'S - Downtown Sandusky is a vibrant culinary spot that perfectly blends a casual waterfront vibe with an impressive menu focused on hearty, flavorful fare. From the moment you step in, the warm, modern interior invites you to relax and savor the experience, enhanced by attentive service and a well-curated beer selection, including 19 beers on tap and various bottled options.

The menu shines with its diverse offerings, balancing classic American favorites with inventive twists. Among the standout dishes is the Coney Sauce, delivering a nostalgic punch of seasoned goodness that complements their All-American Cheeseburger and mouth-watering Mushroom Swiss Burger. For sandwich lovers, Tony’s Original Cheesesteak and the Greek or Chipotle variations reveal a masterful handling of savory fillings and quality bread, truly capturing the essence of a great cheesesteak experience. As one satisfied diner put it, “the cheesesteaks rocked!”

Appetizers and shareables here are as compelling as the mains. The Beer Battered Onion Rings offer a perfect crunch, making them a suitable companion to a cold Blue Moon Belgian White or a refreshing Jack Daniels cocktail. The Fried Green Tomatoes and Deep Fried Ravioli bring a crispy, flavorful start to your meal, while the Fried Guacamole Balls provide a creative flair that elevates traditional finger food. Not to be missed are the Homemade Crab Cakes, a delicate balance of fresh seafood and seasoning that nods to the lakefront location’s access to quality ingredients.

For those seeking something more substantial, the Steak Hogie and Turkey Club Wrap provide satisfying, well-seasoned options that meld textures and flavors seamlessly. The Lake Erie Perch Sandwich, a regional specialty, highlights fresh local fish, expertly fried and nestled in a soft bun, celebrated by repeat visitors for its authentic taste.

Salad choices like the Mediterranean Salad offer a crisp, refreshing contrast to the heavier dishes, perfect for balancing the meal. And for the sweet tooth, the Cherry Cheesecake delivers a rich yet light dessert finish, rounding out the experience beautifully.

Customer feedback reflects a place that excels in both its food and ambiance. The outdoor bar and seating area is frequently praised, offering a wonderful setting for summer evenings by the water. Though service can occasionally lag, especially during quieter times, the overall consensus is that the staff are friendly, knowledgeable, and responsive, with servers like Jabar earning special mention for their helpful recommendations and quick drink service.

In sum, TONY'S - Downtown Sandusky stands out as a must-visit for anyone craving classic American dishes with a twist, paired expertly with a strong drink menu and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether it's a casual night out for burgers and onion rings or a more indulgent meal featuring homemade crab cakes and signature cheesesteaks, Tony’s delivers consistent quality and good vibes, making it a true local favorite near the waterfront.